String Theory by Ray Brimble

View Original

The Science of Altruism

ILLUSTRATION BY EMMANUEL POLANCO

Kudos and thanks to my wonderful wife, Karen, for finding this incredible article by Bonnie Tsui about the work, life, and spirit of scientist, businessman (he once ran Cyberknife), philanthropist, and thinker, James Doty. At his institute at Stanford, he studies why folks who “do good” often “do better” for themselves, as well as those they help. It turns out that kindness is one of the most powerfully beneficial forms of “connectivity.” Doty is proving, scientifically, what we have always known instinctively;  connectivity is a path toward well-being and health for the giver, as well as the receiver. I have always thought this to be one of the most wonderful mysteries of life. If you know someone who is struggling, or perhaps you are struggling yourself, don’t just rely on things like acupuncture and medication — try exercising a little kindness. It’s the best medicine there is.

— Ray Brimble


He Gave Away $30 Million Because It Felt Good

James Doty just may embody the altruism he studies.

WRITTEN BY BONNIE TSUI

Originally published May 23, 2019 by NAUTILUS

James Doty is not a subject under study at the altruism research center that he founded at Stanford in 2008, but he could be. In 2000, after building a fortune as a neurosurgeon and biotech entrepreneur in Silicon Valley, he lost it all in the dotcom crash: $75 million gone in six weeks. Goodbye villa in Tuscany, private island in New Zealand, penthouse in San Francisco. His final asset was stock in a medical-device company he’d once run called Accuray. But it was stock he’d committed to a trust that would benefit the universities he’d attended and programs for AIDS, family, and global health. Doty was $3 million in the hole. Everyone told him to keep the stock for himself. He gave it away—all $30 million of it. “Giving it away has had to be the most personally fulfilling experience I’ve had in my life,” Doty, 63, said on a sunny afternoon at Stanford in 2014. In 2007, Accuray went public at a valuation of $1.3 billion. That generated hundreds of millions for Doty’s donees and zero for him. “I have no regrets,” he said.

FROM WELFARE TO THE PENTHOUSE: “You have to show everyone that you’re not inferior, that you’re as good as they are,” James Doty said of his drive to the high life (photo courtesy of James Doty).

So what exactly is wrong with Doty? Is it normal for a human being to commit a generous act that helps others and not himself? Or is his selfless act merely an act of veiled self-interest? Anthropologists and evolutionary biologists have been wrestling with these questions for decades. Recent research suggests it’s more complicated than that—that evolution has pushed us toward a trait that binds communities and helps them prosper, and that altruistic acts promote individual well-being in biologically measurable ways. These are precisely the kinds of issues and questions that motivated Doty to form—with a seed donation of $150,000 from the Dalai Lama, whom Doty had met in a chance encounter—the Center for Compassion and Altruism Research and Education, or CCARE, part of Stanford’s School of Medicine.

In the past 11 years, CCARE has distinguished itself from other research centers because it’s determinedly multidisciplinary. Its affiliated scientists have conducted studies in areas from neuroscience and psychology to economics and “contemplative traditions” like Buddhism. But CCARE is distinguished in another way: Many of its core findings mirror Doty’s own life. Emiliana Simon-Thomas, a neuroscientist, the science director of the Greater Good Science Center at the University of California, Berkeley, and former associate director of CCARE, sees Doty as a remarkable embodiment of what researchers are learning about altruism. “He rose to absurd riches and found that having every possible need met isn’t better,” she said. “That kind of question motivates him. He’s gone to the extremes of the pendulum, and he’s trying to find the place in between that will bring him the most rich and authentic sense of purpose.”

Doty, an atheist, believes life, especially his own, revolves around the kindness of others. A tall, bearish man with a head of full gray hair, who is by turns pensive and cheerful, Doty acknowledged that he founded the center out of his own self-interest. “Every scientist is inherently biased, but the data is the data,” he said. “I am just as interested in the question of what blocks or prevents compassionate behavior, and what are the documented physiologic benefits, or not.” He added, “All of us have a backstory, and how we function or behave today is a manifestation of what has happened to us in the past.”


Read the full article by Bonnie Tsui on the NAUTILUS